Serving Sarasota, FL since 2009

Goodfellas Cafe & Winery | Restaurant | Sarasota, FL

Ladies can enjoy $2 glasses of wine

every Wednesday night from

3:00 PM to close.

GOOD GALS NIGHT

Finish off your meal with a dessert from Goodfellas Cafe & Winery. Whether you are a cake or pie person, we have a large selection that will satisfy your cravings.

Try One of Our Savory Desserts

Carrot Cake

CAKES OR CUPCAKES (24 PER BATCH)

$21

Chocolate Cocoa

$19

Red Velvet

$21

Blueberry Buckle

$25

Key Lime

$21

Banana

$20

Strawberry

$21

Pineapple Upside-Down

$21

Apple

$20

German Chocolate

$25

Chocolate Peanut Butter

$21

Lemon

$18

Cheesecake

$25

Blueberry Buckle

OTHER TREATS

$25

Brownies

each $2

Focaccia

BREADS

$8

Sub Rolls  8"

$1

Baguette

$3

Ciabatta Loaf

$8

Apple

$10

Pumpkin

$10

Banana

$10

Pumpkin

PIES

$14

French Silk

$16

Key Lime

$16

Peanut Butter

$18

Coconut Cream

$16

Chocolate Chip

$18

Apple

$14

Cream Cheese

$16

Blueberry

$16

Oatmeal

$18

Lemon

$16

$1 each or $10 per Pound

COOKIES

Chocolate Chip

Chocolate White Chip

Snickerdoodle

Italian Wedding

Oatmeal Raisin

Raspberry Linzer Tart

Apricot Linzer Tart

Sugar Cookies

Molasses

Peanut Butter

Red Velvet

Pumpkin

MUFFINS

Banana

$2

Muffin Doughnuts

$2

SEASONAL

Gingerbread Boyz

$2

Buckeyes

4 for $1

Fudge

$13 per Pound

Peppermint Bark

$20 per Pound

Toffee

$30 per Pound

Whoopie Pie Pineapple Upside-Down Cookies Cake Biscott dessert